Sotheby’s MacDonnell Cellar Sale: Strong Sell-Through and Mixed Wine Results

Sotheby's502 lots

A Legacy in Wine | The Family Cellar of Jannine and Robert MacDonnell

Key Takeaways

  • Sotheby's sale realized $2,294,839.
  • Analysis covers 475 of 502 offered lots.
  • Whole-sale sell-through was 97.4%.
  • Average equivalent bottle price across analyzed lots was $583.86.
  • 22 analyzed lots exceeded their observed comparable-price highs in the preceding 360-day history window.
  • Of 475 analyzed lots with hammer prices and both estimates, 249 (52.4%) finished above estimates, 197 (41.5%) within, and 29 (6.1%) below.

Sotheby's sale realized $2,294,839. Analysis covers 475 of 502 offered lots. Whole-sale sell-through was 97.4%.

Auction Snapshot

Auction Overview

Bottle-price analysis covers 475 of 502 catalogue lots. Recent highs compare with the preceding 360 days of recorded results.

Sale total

$2,294,839

Avg bottle price

$584

Sell-through rate

97.4%

Recent high lots

22

% above estimate

52.4%

% below estimate

6.1%

Provider Benchmark

Sell-through vs prior auctions

Estimate Performance

Hammer prices compared with estimates across 475 lots.

Price Distribution

Bottle price ranges in USD (binned)

Price Evolution Spotlight

Select a wine to explore its recent auction trajectory.

Vigneto di Monte Lodoletta 1997 Romano dal Forno (6 BT) (1997)

Change over series: 58.3%

58.3% over 306 days Last sale vs median: 212.9%

Market Pulse

Sotheby's sale realized $2,294,839. Analysis covers 475 of 502 offered lots. Whole-sale sell-through was 97.4%. The analyzed lots account for $2,273,899 of realized value. Average equivalent bottle price across analyzed lots was $583.86. Whole-sale realized value per offered lot was $4,571.39 including unsold lots in the denominator. The median sale total across 6 prior auctions from this provider in USD was $1,346,487. 22 analyzed lots exceeded their observed comparable-price highs in the preceding 360-day history window.

Estimate Performance

Of 475 analyzed lots with hammer prices and both estimates, 249 (52.4%) finished above estimates, 197 (41.5%) within, and 29 (6.1%) below. All percentages use this same sample. Hammer prices exclude buyer premium.

Wine Analysis

Sotheby’s “A Legacy in Wine | The Family Cellar of Jannine and Robert MacDonnell” closed on October 24, 2026, with a whole-sale realized total of $2,294,839. The analysis covers 475 lots, or 475 of 502 total lots. Results were mixed at the individual-wine level, despite strong overall clearance.

Breakout Lots and Soft Spots

The six-bottle lot of Vigneto di Monte Lodoletta 1997 Romano dal Forno achieved $395.83 per bottle, above its recent comparable range of $82.70 to $250 and more than three times its five-sale median of $126.50. This was an observed comparable-price high within the 360-day history window, based on five recent comparable transactions. Its result was notably strong against those comparables, even though it fell below the stated $1,200 to $1,600 estimate for the lot.

Opus One 1984 sold for $563 per bottle, above its five-sale median of $360 and the recent range of $174 to $475.64. It was an observed comparable-price high within the 360-day history window. By contrast, Barolo, Le Rocche del Falletto di Serralunga d'Alba 1999 Bruno Giacosa in a three-litre format brought $125 per bottle, versus a recent range of $229.17 to $400 and a five-sale median of $364.58. This was an observed comparable-price low within the 360-day history window, with five recent comparable transactions.

Other softer results included Barbaresco Asili di Barbaresco 1997 Bruno Giacosa in six magnums at $88.58 per bottle equivalent, against a five-sale median of $227.27, and Barolo Rocche dell'Annunziata Torriglione 2000 Roberto Voerzio at $125 per bottle, versus a five-sale median of $317.14. These results underscore the importance of format and lot-level comparison rather than relying on broad producer or regional labels.

Spotlight Wines

Vigneto di Monte Lodoletta 1997 Romano dal Forno recorded $395.83 per bottle in the six-bottle Sotheby’s lot. In the one-year series of equivalent bottle prices from trusted major auction houses, the recent observations ranged from $106.22 to $250 before this result. The new sale price is 58% above the prior listed high of $250, but the series is limited to five transactions and includes differing pack sizes and formats. The 360-day comparable-price high should be understood within that window, not as an all-time record.

Opus One 1984 brought $563, compared with $473 at K&L Wines in August and $416.67 per bottle equivalent for a six-bottle lot in May. The one-year series includes eight observations across trusted major auction houses, with earlier sales commonly between $300 and $375. This October result is 19% above the August price and is the highest observed in that 365-day series. It also exceeds the five-comparable recent maximum of $475.64, making it an observed comparable-price high within the stated 360-day window.

Chambertin, Clos de Bèze 1996 Louis Jadot sold in a 12-bottle lot for $270.83 per bottle. The one-year series shows a rise from $166.67 in March to $250 in May and then to $270.83 in October, an increase of about 63% from the March observation. The six price-history observations are still a limited sample, though the latest result sits above the recent comparable range of $166.67 to $250. It qualifies as an observed comparable-price high within the 360-day window, rather than an all-time record.

Echézeaux 2002 Emmanuel Rouget reached $1,125 per bottle in a 10-bottle lot. The five-observation one-year series is mixed, ranging from $937.50 to $1,115.33 before the October result. The latest price is about 20% above the July observation at $937.50, but only slightly above the May result of $1,115.33. The observed comparable-price high is within the 360-day history window and rests on five transactions, so it is a narrow market signal rather than evidence of a sustained trend.

Outlook

The sale paired high clearance with sharply different results by wine and format. A small number of bottles and collections exceeded recent comparable prices, while several Italian wines and large-format lots sold well below recent medians. For collectors, the most useful signals are the individual results against recent ranges, with attention to lot size and format. The one-year spotlight histories offer context, but their limited transaction counts counsel against treating single-sale moves as durable trends.

In summary, the MacDonnell sale achieved $2,294,839 in whole-sale proceeds and sold 489 of 502 lots.

Notable Lots

Record prices and standout lots from this sale. Prices are normalized per bottle; lot totals are shown when available.

Sold per bottle$396
Lot total$2,375
Recent median / bottle$127
Sold per bottle$563
Lot total$563
Recent median / bottle$360
Sold per bottle$271
Lot total$3,250
Recent median / bottle$200
Sold per bottle$528
Lot total$4,750
Recent median / bottle$401
Sold per bottle$583
Lot total$1,750
Recent median / bottle$450
Sold per bottle$1,125
Lot total$11,250
Recent median / bottle$1,018
Sold per bottle$406
Lot total$406
Recent median / bottle$231
Sold per bottle$813
Lot total$813
Recent median / bottle$478