Bonhams Rare by Design Whisky and Tequila Auction: Strong Select Results, Lower Sell-Through
Rare by Design: Exceptional Whiskies, Tequilas & C
Key Takeaways
- Bonhams sale realized $398,850.
- Analysis covers 140 of 264 offered lots.
- Whole-sale sell-through was 78.4%.
- Average equivalent bottle price across analyzed lots was $1,251.36.
- 6 analyzed lots exceeded their observed comparable-price highs in the preceding 360-day history window.
- Of 140 analyzed lots with hammer prices and both estimates, 12 (8.6%) finished above estimates, 59 (42.1%) within, and 69 (49.3%) below.
Bonhams sale realized $398,850. Analysis covers 140 of 264 offered lots. Whole-sale sell-through was 78.4%.
Auction Snapshot
Auction Overview
Bottle-price analysis covers 140 of 264 catalogue lots. Recent highs compare with the preceding 360 days of recorded results.
Sale total
$398,850
Avg bottle price
$1,251
Sell-through rate
78.4%
Recent high lots
6
% above estimate
8.6%
% below estimate
49.3%
Provider Benchmark
Sell-through vs prior auctions
Estimate Performance
Hammer prices compared with estimates across 140 lots.
Price Distribution
Bottle price ranges in USD (binned)
Price Evolution Spotlight
Select a wine to explore its recent auction trajectory.
George T. Stagg, 2005 (1 bottle, 750ml) (2005)
Change over series: -17.6%
Market Pulse
Bonhams sale realized $398,850. Analysis covers 140 of 264 offered lots. Whole-sale sell-through was 78.4%. The analyzed lots account for $210,750 of realized value. Average equivalent bottle price across analyzed lots was $1,251.36. Whole-sale realized value per offered lot was $1,510.80 including unsold lots in the denominator. The median sale total across 6 prior auctions from this provider in USD was $285,723. 6 analyzed lots exceeded their observed comparable-price highs in the preceding 360-day history window.
Estimate Performance
Of 140 analyzed lots with hammer prices and both estimates, 12 (8.6%) finished above estimates, 59 (42.1%) within, and 69 (49.3%) below. All percentages use this same sample. Hammer prices exclude buyer premium.
Wine Analysis
Bonhams’ “Rare by Design: Exceptional Whiskies, Tequilas & C” sale closed on October 26, 2026, with a whole-sale realized total of $398,850 from 207 sold lots out of 264 offered. The detailed analysis covers 140 of the 264 catalogue lots, rather than the full sale. The data records six observed comparable-price highs within the 360-day history window, not all-time records.
Breakout Lots and Soft Spots
The strongest comparable-price result was The Macallan Anniversary Malt 25 Years Old, 1970, at $4,500 per bottle. That was above its recent $2,109.98 $3,400 estimate. It is an observed comparable-price high within 360 days, not an all-time record.
Clase Azul DĂa de Muertos, 2022, sold at $1,593.75 per bottle, 74.3% above its recent median of $914.25 and above the previous observed high of $1,408.64. Yet the result remained well below its $2,600-$3,400 estimate. The 2024 DĂa de Muertos reached $1,500 per bottle, against a recent median of $948.75 and prior high of $1,224.75, but also fell short of the same estimate range. Both are observed comparable-price highs within the 360-day window, illustrating the difference between outperforming recent transactions and meeting an estimate.
Results were not uniformly strong. Ardbeg Airigh Nam Beist, 1990, achieved $287.50 per bottle, below its $465.75 recent median and the $400 $523.25. William Larue Weller, 2009, realized $2,125 $3,250. The outcomes were inside that range but below the median. These results provide useful counterpoints to the sale’s standout prices.
Spotlight Wines
George T. Stagg, 2005 sold for $1,750 per bottle at Bonhams, within its $1,400 $2,125. The limited, uneven set of observations shows substantial price variation rather than a smooth directional trend.
Thomas H. Handy Sazerac Rye, 2012 reached $525, near the top of its $420-$550 estimate. The 365-day trusted auction-house series includes three Sotheby’s results at $375 in June and a Bonhams result at $563.20 in February. The October price was 40% above the recent five-transaction median of $375, but the small sample supports a comparison of individual outcomes, not a broader trend claim.
William Larue Weller, 2009 sold for $2,125-$2,250 per bottle across three Bonhams lots. In the 365-day trusted auction-house series, comparable prices ranged from $1,375 to $3,250, including a $3,250 Sotheby’s result in January and $1,375 in September. Bonhams’ prices sit between those observations and below the five-transaction median of $2,961.25. The result demonstrates dispersion among recent sales rather than a consistent one-way movement.
George T. Stagg, 2013 realized $937.50, inside its $750-$1,000 estimate and close to the $862.50 recent five-transaction median. The 365-day trusted auction-house series runs from $920 to $1,188, with two K&L Wines results at $920 and a January Sotheby’s result at $1,188. Bonhams’ outcome is near the lower end of the observed range and broadly consistent with the recent cluster.
Outlook
This sale paired a strong whole-sale total and elevated value per offered lot with a below-benchmark sell-through rate. Within the analyzed sample, many lots cleared below estimate, while selected whiskies and tequilas substantially exceeded recent comparable prices. The evidence favors a lot-by-lot reading: a few exceptional results should not be treated as a market-wide price signal, and the available histories are limited to observed transactions. Collectors can use recent ranges and estimate gaps together when assessing similar offerings, while recognizing that comparable-sale samples vary in size.
Notable Lots
Record prices and standout lots from this sale. Prices are normalized per bottle; lot totals are shown when available.